Sign in

    U-Haul Holding Co (UHAL)

    UHAL Q4 2025: U-Box Transactions Surge 20%, Fueling Revenue Growth

    Reported on May 29, 2025 (After Market Close)
    Pre-Earnings Price$63.23Last close (May 29, 2025)
    Post-Earnings Price$63.23Open (May 30, 2025)
    Price Change
    $0.00(0.00%)
    • Robust U-Box Growth: The Q&A highlighted that U-Box moving transactions are growing at over 20%, with the segment expanding at roughly three times the pace of the truck share business. This underexplored market offers significant room for future growth.
    • Resilient Self-Storage Expansion: Management noted strong real estate investments and steady lease-up performance in new self-storage facilities, with facilities expected to cover costs at around 70% occupancy. This positions the business for solid top-line growth over the near to medium term.
    • Experienced Cost Management & Value Optimization: Executives emphasized proactive strategies to manage rising depreciation and tariff concerns while also discussing potential share repurchase and a disconnect in valuation. This indicates that management is focused on both operational efficiency and unlocking shareholder value.
    • High fleet depreciation pressures: Management highlighted that higher-than-projected equipment acquisition costs amid supply shortages have led to significant increases in depreciation expenses, which, coupled with rising maintenance costs, may continue to pressure margins.
    • Earnings volatility from investment fluctuations: The Property and Casualty segment saw operating profits drop from $25 million to $10 million due to market-driven valuation swings in held common stocks, introducing volatility in earnings performance.
    • Persistent valuation gap in core self-storage: Despite strong growth in self-storage and U-Box segments, analysts observed that the business is undervalued relative to peers, with management providing limited concrete measures to close this gap, potentially hindering capital efficiency and share price performance.
    MetricYoY ChangeReason

    Total Revenue

    +12.6% (from $1,095.98M to $1,233.47M)

    Robust growth in core operations drove the increase, with higher Moving & Storage performance including self‐moving equipment rental and self-storage revenue improvements compared to Q4 2024, which saw lower figures.

    Property & Casualty Insurance Revenue

    -88% (from $34.06M to $4.15M)

    A steep decline in this segment reflects a dramatic drop in premiums sold in conjunction with rental transactions and potential operational restructuring, contrasting with stronger performance in preceding periods.

    Insurance Premiums

    +50% (from $21.5M to $32.35M)

    A significant surge in premiums likely results from increased moving and storage transactions that boost policy sales, reversing the subdued performance seen in Q4 2024.

    Life Insurance Performance

    Reversal from +$55.3M to -$82.99M

    A dramatic deterioration occurred due to rising claims, higher operating expenses, and adverse market conditions impacting investment returns, marking an abrupt shift from a profitable Q4 2024.

    Net Investment and Interest Income

    Turnaround from -$40.25M to +$36.57M

    A notable rebound was driven by improved interest rate conditions and a reclassification of income, which reversed prior negative results and delivered a positive turnaround compared to the previous period.

    Pretax Earnings

    Plummeted from $13,661K to -$114,514K

    Substantial cost pressures including increased depreciation expense on both rental fleet and other assets, lower gains on asset disposals, and rising operating costs contributed to the steep decline in pretax earnings relative to Q4 2024.

    Net Earnings

    Worsened from -$863K to -$82,291K

    The cumulative impact of lower operational performance and increased expenses across key segments eroded nearly breakeven results from Q4 2024, leading to a deep net loss in Q4 2025.

    MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange

    Net Fleet Capital Expenditures

    FY 2026

    no prior guidance

    $1.295 billion (compared to ~$1.211 billion in FY 2025)

    no prior guidance

    U-Box Growth

    FY 2026

    no prior guidance

    Plus 20% range

    no prior guidance

    Self-Storage Occupancy

    FY 2026

    no prior guidance

    Approaching 70% occupancy

    no prior guidance

    TopicPrevious MentionsCurrent PeriodTrend

    U-Box and Moving Services Growth

    Q1–Q3: Repeatedly highlighted as a growth engine with strong revenue contributions, plus 20% range increases in U-Box moving and storage transactions and steady gains in moving services rental revenue

    Q4: U-Box continued to show very strong growth with high transaction rates, expanding storage capacity nearly 25% over the past 12 months; moving services also maintained steady revenue increases

    Recurring positive momentum with reinforcing growth sentiment

    Self-Storage Expansion and Performance

    Q1–Q3: Consistently discussed aggressive expansion with large additions, active development pipelines, and improving revenue per occupied foot but noted occupancy challenges and slower lease‐up in later years

    Q4: Continued aggressive expansion with 82 new locations, over 6.5 million new net rentable square feet added, but with some occupancy declines across owned locations and a sizable pipeline that poses near-term EBITDA risks

    Recurring strategic focus with mixed sentiment – strong expansion but caution over occupancy and pace of lease-up

    Competitive Differentiation and Market Dominance

    Q1–Q3: Emphasized through innovations in customer service, cost and pricing advantages, and integrated offerings (notably U-Box’s service benefits and broad distribution network)

    Q4: Indirectly referenced via focus on operational excellence in customer experience and U-Box growth, though less explicit compared to previous periods

    Recurring core strength with slightly less emphasis in explicit discussion but still supportive of market positioning

    Cost Management and Operating Expense Pressures

    Q1–Q3: Noted rising operating costs driven by personnel, liabilities, and OEM pricing pressures; partial successes in reducing fleet repair costs and implementing cost controls

    Q4: Operating expenses increased notably due to higher personnel, utilities, and fleet liability costs, yet there was a decline in fleet repair costs; overall pressures remain while efforts to normalize fleet depreciation continue

    Consistently challenging with moderate improvements in specific areas but persistent cost pressures remain

    Fleet Depreciation and Maintenance Cost Challenges

    Q1–Q3: Highlighted increasing depreciation due to high acquisition costs and softer resale markets with gradual improvements in maintenance cost reductions; challenges persisted across periods

    Q4: Depreciation remained a significant issue, contributing to earnings declines while maintenance costs declined further due to improved fleet rotation and newer vehicles

    Recurring challenge with expectations of normalization over a multi‐year cycle

    Financial Liquidity and Debt/Leverage Risks

    Q1–Q3: Maintained focus on strong liquidity positions supported by significant cash availability and borrowing capacity against real estate; active management of cash balances and debt maturities was emphasized

    Q4: Reported liquidity of $1.348 billion in the Moving and Storage segment along with continued emphasis on high liquidity and flexibility amid market uncertainties

    Consistently strong liquidity profiles with stable execution in debt management

    Valuation Gaps and Capital Return Strategies

    Q1: Not discussed; Q2–Q3: Analysts and executives raised concerns over a valuation gap between self‑storage/U‑Box operations and peers, with discussions on slowing capital investment and potential asset partitioning, though strategies remained tentative

    Q4: Continued recognition of an undervaluation in non‑truck segments with debates over potential share repurchases and sale of insurance businesses to optimize value; no definitive actions were announced

    Emerging and persistent concern with ongoing debate and potential strategic shifts to unlock value

    Earnings Volatility from Investment Fluctuations

    Q1–Q3: No discussion on earnings volatility from investment fluctuations was noted

    Q4: Earnings volatility was highlighted through a $10 million swing in operating profits due to changes in the market value of held common stock, emphasizing the impact of investment fluctuations on earnings

    New topic in Q4 reflecting increased attention to market-related volatility

    Capacity and Expansion Risks in Self-Storage

    Q1–Q3: Frequently mentioned as a concern with capacity being added faster than occupancy growth; challenges with slower lease‑up periods and risks in acquiring or developing new properties were detailed with seasoning processes required for stabilization

    Q4: Continued discussion of risks arising from aggressive expansion, significant new pipeline developments, and potential delays in reaching EBITDA positivity due to slower occupancy ramp-up in later lease‑up stages

    Recurring risk with persistent concerns that may deepen if occupancy slowdowns persist

    Shifting Sentiments in One‑Way Transaction Demand

    Q1–Q3: Initially, slight growth in one‑way moves was noted in Q1 (reflecting consumer optimism), though Q2 saw stagnant volumes offset by higher revenue per transaction, and Q3 reported declines in volume balanced by higher revenue per mile gains; overall, one‑way demand was mixed

    Q4: No explicit discussion was provided regarding one‑way transaction sentiment though broader moving trends and consumer behavior were indirectly mentioned

    Discussion has receded in Q4, suggesting reduced focus on one‑way transaction metrics while earlier periods reflected mixed but improving sentiment

    1. Top-Line Growth
      Q: Outlook for top-line growth?
      A: Management expects modest, consistent growth around 2–3% driven by positive customer sentiment and precise execution.

    2. Depreciation Impact
      Q: How should we view depreciation?
      A: They explained that while storage depreciation builds value, truck depreciation is a real expense caused by high acquisition costs, and they expect normalization over time.

    3. Share Repurchase
      Q: Any plans for buybacks?
      A: Although the valuation gap is noted, management has no immediate proposal for share repurchases, emphasizing liquidity and flexibility instead.

    4. Real Estate Investment
      Q: What is FY26 CapEx outlook?
      A: The focus remains on steady, strategic real estate investment with deliberate expansion rather than emergency construction, supporting long-term growth.

    5. U-Box Growth
      Q: How is U-Box performing relative to moving?
      A: U-Box moving transactions are growing strongly in the high 20% range, outpacing storage, signaling a promising future for this segment.

    6. Property & Casualty Swing
      Q: Why did P&C profits drop sharply?
      A: The decline from $25M to $10M was due to market revaluation of held common stock rather than operational issues.

    7. Fleet & Maintenance Costs
      Q: How is the fleet’s age and cost profile evolving?
      A: The fleet is regaining its pre-COVID quality with improved truck conditions, though increased depreciation reflects recent higher acquisition prices; overall, quality and maintenance expectations remain strong.